Carolina Coin Review: A Comprehensive Look at This Precious Metal Dealer

Carolina Coin Review

Disclaimer: Many or all of the companies listed here may provide compensation to us. This is how we maintain our free service for consumers. Compensation, along with hours of in-depth editorial research, determines where & how companies appear below.

Carolina Coin is a family-owned and operated business that has been buying and selling coins, currency, and precious metals since 1978. They are located in historic Charleston, SC, focusing on providing excellent customer service and offering a wide variety of numismatic items.

Our #1 Recommended Company Is Currently Running A Special Promotion!

You have the chance to get back 10% of your order in FREE silver! That would mean $5,000 in free silver on a $50,000 order. Or $10,000 in free silver on a $100,000 order!

>> Get A Free Investment Kit & Learn About This Special Offer Here <<

Details about this same company:

  • 1,000+ 5 star ratings
  • Protects over $1 BILLION dollars in retirement savings
  • AAA customer rated
  • A+ BBB Rating
  • 5x Inc 500 winner
  • 2021 company of the year

Get your free investment kit and learn about the special promotion above, or continue with this Carolina Coin review below...

Carolina Coin Products

Carolina Coin Review

Carolina Coin offers free appraisals, and they are always looking to buy collections large and small. They also offer consignment services and can help you sell coins, currency, or precious metal items. In addition to its brick-and-mortar store, Carolina Coin has an active online presence, an extensive website, and an eBay store.

Whether you're looking to buy or sell, Carolina Coin is a great resource for all your numismatic needs. Please keep reading for our review of Carolina Coin's pros and cons!

Pros & Cons of Carolina Coin


One benefit of investing in Carolina Coin is that they offer a wide variety of coin designs. There are coins available featuring popular sports teams, movies, and more. This makes them a great option for collectors or investors who want to add some diversity to their portfolios.

Another benefit is that Carolina Coin offers a buy-back guarantee. This means that if you decide you no longer want your coins, you can return them for the purchase price within 30 days.

Their machines are reliable and easy to use, and their customer service is top-notch. In addition, Carolina Coin offers several unique features that set them apart from its competitors.

  • Carolina Coin has been in business for over 40 years, so they have a lot of experience in the industry.
  • They offer a wide variety of services, including coin trading, gold and silver buying and selling, and more.
  • They are accredited by the Better Business Bureau (BBB) with an A+ rating.
  • Carolina Coin is a member of the American Numismatic Association (ANA), which is the largest organization of coin collectors and dealers in the world.
  • They have an extensive online presence, an informative website, an active social media accounts.


First, their fees for buying and selling coins are on the high spectrum. For example, they charge a 4% commission on all sales, and their buy prices are often below the spot price of gold. In addition, Carolina Coin has been known to be slow in processing orders, and they have been known to sell fake or counterfeit coins. As a result, it is important to do your research before working with this company.

  • Some customers have complained that Carolina Coin's customer service is not very responsive.
  • They offer such a wide variety of coin designs that it can be difficult to find liquidity when selling your coins.
  • Another potential issue is that the value of your coins may fluctuate based on the current market conditions. As with any investment, there is always risk involved.
  • Another con is that they charge a commission on all sales, which can add up if you buy or sell multiple items. Also, their online catalog can be difficult to navigate.
  • Another con is that they charge a commission on all sales, which can add up if you buy or sell multiple items. Also, their online catalog can be difficult to navigate.
  • Additionally, they have been known to sell counterfeit coins occasionally, so buyers should be sure to do their research before making a purchase.
Carolina Coin Review

Overall, Carolina Coin is a reputable company with a long history in the coin industry. However, potential buyers should know the possible cons before doing business with them.

When buying or selling gold and silver, many people turn to precious metal dealers like Carolina Coin. But what exactly is a precious metal dealer? In short, precious metal dealers are businesses that buy and sell gold, silver, platinum, and palladium. Some precious metal dealers also deal in rare coins and other collectibles.

Precious metal dealers usually have a lot of experience in the industry and are knowledgeable about the market value of different metals. They can advise when to buy or sell based on current market conditions. Most precious metal dealers have an online presence with an informative website and active social media accounts.

Final Verdict

If you're considering working with a precious metal dealer like Carolina Coin, it's important to do your research first. Make sure to read reviews from past customers and check out their accreditations (like the Better Business Bureau rating).

Overall, Carolina Coin is a reputable precious metal dealer with a lot of experience in the industry. They offer a wide variety of services and are accredited by the Better Business Bureau (BBB) with an A+ rating. Carolina Coin is worth considering if you're looking for a reliable place to buy or sell coins! 

However, if you're looking for outstanding customer service, you may want to look elsewhere. Have you had any experiences with Carolina Coin? We'd love to hear about them in the comments below!

Don't Forget Your Free Silver & Investment Kit!

Even if you aren't ready to invest right now, it would be smart to learn how you can use precious metals to get major tax advantages & retirement savings benefits so that you can plan for the future! And if you are ready to invest, you may as well get some free silver with your investment!

>> Get Your Free Investment Kit & Learn More About The Free Silver Offer Here <<